Chain Reaction · Geopolitics · Europe

Russia and Ukraine attack ports, choking off grain and oilseed exports

Port attacks threaten grain and oilseed exports for import-dependent countries in Africa and South Asia as India seeks safer Black Sea shipping.

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi shakes hands with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy during an official meeting.
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi shakes hands with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy during an official meeting.Photo: ThePrint

Shipping safety in the Black Sea turns on whether attacks on shipping ease.

A food corridor would let ships move. India’s proposals also raise the possibility of non-attack arrangements around grain and energy exports. That makes the bargain harder: a corridor plan depends on reducing attacks on ports and shipping, while Russia and Ukraine have attacked one another’s ports.

India’s proposal starts with shipping security, not with wheat prices. India’s proposals for a ceasefire revolve around the safety of commercial shipping in the Black Sea and the flow of grain and energy supplies, Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said Tuesday, according to a Tuesday account from theprint.in. In another quoted formulation, India has been engaging both sides on grain and energy exports and on “non-attack possibilities.”

India also has a balance-sheet reason to care about who can load cargo. In the 2025-26 marketing year, India imported 1.46 million tonnes of sunflower oil from Russia and 443,000 tonnes from Ukraine, according to the Indian Solvent Extractors’ Association (SEA), in a Tuesday account from Al Jazeera. That gives India a direct food-oil exposure alongside its diplomacy.

The route is hard to reopen because the ports themselves are part of the fight. Russia has intensified strikes on Ukraine’s Odesa ports, which normally handle about 90 percent of its grain shipments, while Ukraine has hit Russian grain terminals, according to a Tuesday account from Al Jazeera. Safe-passage terms alone would not reduce attacks on the ports.

The earlier model worked, then broke. The United Nations- and Turkiye-brokered Black Sea Grain Initiative allowed nearly 33 million tonnes of food to leave three Ukrainian ports from July 2022 before Russia withdrew a year later, according to a Tuesday account from Al Jazeera. The same account also said Russia walked away from the last grain deal in 2023.

A bargain around non-attack could still reopen the route if it gives both sides enough assurance that loading grain will not hand the other side an easy target.

Skepticism has a named operational reason. Hess said earlier attempts towards a standalone corridor failed “because Russia kept attacking Ukrainian ports”, and that shipping recovered only when Ukraine used naval drones to push Russia’s fleet away, according to a Tuesday account from Al Jazeera. In that version, bargaining followed battlefield distance; it did not create it.

Importers Have Little Control

Ukraine’s farm sector faces a problem if output cannot leave. Maksym Hopka, an analyst at the Ukrainian Agribusiness Club, estimated that Ukraine’s agricultural output totaled about 3.7 million metric tons in July, of which about 2.7 million metric tons comprised grain, DW reported in August. Hopka also calculated that exports of agricultural produce would drop by about 9 million metric tons between August and October, and that losses could amount to about $1.9 billion.

Russian port operators face a different strain. The flow of cargo traffic through Russia’s southern ports has nearly come to a halt amid deteriorating security in the Azov and Black Sea basin, while Moscow has refused requests for financial assistance, Ukraine’s Foreign Intelligence Service (SZRU) reported, according to a Monday account from united24media.com. The agency estimates that compensating port operators for labor costs alone would require between $78.4 million and $95 million annually from Russia’s federal budget.

Importers are the outside players with little control over the attacks. Russia and Ukraine have attacked one another’s ports this year, choking off grain and oilseed exports that feed import-dependent countries in Africa and South Asia and leaving India short of sunflower oil, according to a Tuesday account from Al Jazeera. That puts pressure on India’s sunflower-oil buyers as well as other importers.

The talks also sit inside a wider negotiation over the war. Trilateral talks involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States began in the United Arab Emirates to explore a peaceful resolution to a conflict that has disrupted global food and energy supplies, according to a Tuesday account from www.newindianexpress.com. The disruption puts pressure on import-dependent countries.

With no scheduled decision named in the public reports, the practical test is blunt: continued attacks and closed capacity support the security reading; fewer attacks and reopened capacity would make India’s Black Sea proposal look workable.

What would change it. Reports of fewer attacks and reopened grain export capacity would break the security-first reading and support the corridor case.

The Last Time

The Black Sea Grain Initiative

What Rhymes

It was United Nations- and Turkiye-brokered and moved food from three Ukrainian ports; reports now again describe grain and Black Sea shipping safety.

What Is Different

Russia withdrew a year later, while current reports describe attacks on ports and shipping capacity across the Azov and Black Sea basin.

What It Means for the Forecast

The earlier deal suggests tonnage can move when port access and security hold, but the forecast should lean on attacks and capacity, not diplomatic language alone.

Source: Al Jazeera, Nov 10, 2026

Sources

theprint.in Nov. 10Al Jazeera Nov. 10newindianexpress.com Nov. 10DW Aug. 21united24media.com Nov. 9indianewengland.com Nov. 9

23 statements, each tied to its sourceWhat each statement rests onHow ARCANE checks a story

Sources
S1theprint.inRetrieved Nov 10, 2026
S2Al JazeeraRetrieved Nov 10, 2026
S3newindianexpress.comRetrieved Nov 10, 2026
S4DWRetrieved Nov 10, 2026
S5united24media.comRetrieved Nov 10, 2026
S6indianewengland.comRetrieved Nov 10, 2026
All 6 sources were retrieved from their exact links, so a later change to any of them would be detectable
What each statement rests on (23)
reportedS1

New Delhi: India’s proposals for a ceasefire in the Russia-Ukraine war revolve around ensuring safety of commercial shipping in the Black Sea and the flow of grain and energy supplies, Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said Tuesday.

reportedS1

“In keeping with this idea to bring peace, India has been engaging both sides with certain ideas such as safety of shipping in the Black Sea, addressing immediate concerns of Russia and Ukraine on grain and energy exports, and non-attack possibilities.”

reportedS2

Russia has intensified strikes on Ukraine’s Odesa ports, which normally handle about 90 percent of its grain shipments, while Ukraine has hit Russian grain terminals.

reportedS2

By mid-August, attacks on shipping had shut down more than 97 percent of Russia and Ukraine’s grain export capacity in the Azov and Black Sea basin, according to Reuters.

reportedS2

The last deal of this kind, the United Nations- and Turkiye-brokered Black Sea Grain Initiative, allowed nearly 33 million tonnes of food to leave three Ukrainian ports from July 2022, before Russia withdrew a year later.

reportedS2

In the 2025-26 marketing year, India imported 1.46 million tonnes of sunflower oil from Russia and 443,000 tonnes from Ukraine, according to the Indian Solvent Extractors’ Association (SEA), alongside large volumes of Russian crude.

reportedS2

Russia and Ukraine have attacked one another’s ports this year, choking off grain and oilseed exports that feed import-dependent countries in Africa and South Asia, and leaving India short of sunflower oil.

reportedS2

Before Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022, about a third of the world’s grain exports passed through the Black Sea, with Ukraine supplying a tenth of global wheat exports and 15 percent of maize, Al Jazeera has reported .

reportedS2

Hess said earlier attempts towards a standalone corridor failed “because Russia kept attacking Ukrainian ports”, and that shipping recovered only when Ukraine used naval drones to push Russia’s fleet away.

reportedS2

Russia, for its part, walked away from the last grain deal in 2023.

reportedS3

Following his conversation with Modi, Zelenskyy said the two leaders had discussed Russia's blockade of grain exports through the Black Sea.

reportedS3

The statement came as trilateral talks involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States began in the United Arab Emirates to explore a peaceful resolution to the conflict, which has disrupted global food and energy supplies.

reportedS3

India is engaging with both Russia and Ukraine on a range of proposals aimed at de-escalating the nearly five-year conflict, including ensuring the safety of shipping in the Black Sea, facilitating grain and energy exports and exploring possibilities for non-attack arrangements, the Ministry of External Affairs said on Tuesday.

reportedS4

Maksym Hopka, an analyst at the Ukrainian Agribusiness Club, estimates that Ukraine's agricultural output totaled about 3.7 million metric tons in July, of which about 2.7 million metric tons comprised grain.

reportedS4

Hopka has calculated that Ukraine's exports of agricultural produce  will drop by about 9 million metric tons between August and October, and that losses could amount to about $1.9 billion.

reportedS5

Cargo traffic through Russia’s southern ports has nearly halted amid deteriorating security in the Azov–Black Sea basin, while Moscow has refused requests for financial assistance, Ukraine’s Foreign Intelligence Service (SZRU) reported on November 9.

reportedS5

The agency estimates that compensating port operators for labor costs alone would require between $78.4 million and $95 million annually from Russia’s federal budget.

reportedS6

International India Offers to Help Restore Black Sea Grain Exports as Modi, Zelensky Discuss Ukraine Peace Efforts

reportedS6

The President emphasised that Ukraine always has a constructive approach, and the same willingness to de-escalate from Russia is needed,” the statement said.

inferred

The Black Sea grain fight now looks less like a corridor problem than a mutual-strike problem, which makes India’s mediation harder to judge.

financial_implication

On the reported data, disruption of grain and oilseed exports shifts pressure toward import-dependent countries in Africa and South Asia and India's sunflower-oil buyers.

inferred

A corridor plan depends on reducing attacks on ports and shipping, because the reports describe closed capacity and attacks by both Russia and Ukraine.

testable

The thesis would be confirmed by continued public reports of attacks or shut capacity and weakened by reports that attacks stop and capacity reopens.

Alpha's read · open

The corridor case holds only if attacks on Black Sea and Azov shipping capacity ease; otherwise grain diplomacy is a security bargain, not a shipping fix.

Screen for this structure

Geopolitics · europe

Open in screener